Get Started

Mistakes to Avoid When Selling a Home

March 25, 2025

The process of selling your home is a long and complex undertaking that can overwhelm homeowners who aren’t prepared. If you’re a first-time home seller or if you’re trying to sell without a realtor, you may not be aware of the mistakes you can make during the sales process.

Worry not, because in this guide, we’ll walk you through everything you should steer clear of when selling your house to ensure a smooth and fulfilling sale.

What Are Common Mistakes When Selling A Home?

When selling a home, many sellers can make mistakes that can lead to prolonged market time, lower offers, or even failed sales. Knowing and understanding these common mistakes can help you avoid them, giving you the best chance for a successful sale. Here are some of the most common mistakes to avoid when selling your home.

Pricing Your Home Incorrectly

Overpricing or underpricing your home is one of the most common mistakes homeowners make when selling. In fact, around 17% of home sellers rate correctly pricing your home as the most difficult task to accomplish. It’s easy to believe that your home is worth a certain price but without information about the local housing market, it’s hard to find an accurate price point.

If your house is priced too high, it will stay on the market too long, leading potential buyers to assume there are underlying issues with the property. Conversely, pricing your home too low will end up cutting your profits significantly, even if you find a buyer quickly.

To avoid this mistake, conduct thorough market research or consult a real estate agent for a comparative market analysis (CMA). This analysis will help you understand what similar homes in your area have sold for recently. Comparing your home to others with similar sizes and amenities can help you set a compelling price.

Bar chart comparing average days on market for well-priced versus overpriced homes. Well-priced homes have fewer days, while overpriced homes have significantly more. Title: Average Days on Market: Well-Priced vs. Overpriced Homes.
Average Days on Market: Well-Priced vs. Overpriced Homes

If your home has been on the market for an extended period without offers, consider adjusting the price. Regularly reviewing your pricing strategy based on feedback from showings and market conditions can help keep your listing competitive.

Skipping Home Preparation

Another common mistake is neglecting home preparation. Sellers often underestimate the importance of making their homes appealing to potential buyers. Presenting your home in a comfortable and aesthetically pleasing way can make potential buyers see themselves living there.

Before listing your home, address any necessary repairs, such as fixing leaky faucets, patching holes in walls, or repainting your home’s facade. A well-maintained home creates a positive first impression and can significantly influence buyer perception.

Additionally, decluttering and staging your home can enhance its appeal. Make sure that your space is clean and organized, with minimum clutter. Consider hiring a professional stager if you're unsure how to best showcase your home's features.

Flowchart titled Common Home Repairs with icons and labels: Leaks and water damage (faucet), Holes and cracks (burst symbol), Outdated or broken fixtures (light bulb), Faulty HVAC systems (heating icon), Electrical issues (wire and plug).
Common Home Repairs

Poor Marketing

Effective marketing is important if you want your home to get seen by the right potential buyers. Traditional methods like yard signs or newspaper ads are a great start, but relying solely on those methods can limit your home's exposure. 

Utilize various marketing strategies, including online listings on popular real estate websites, social media promotion, virtual tours, and professional photography. High-quality images can make a significant difference since many buyers begin their search online. Hosting open houses can also be beneficial. These events allow multiple potential buyers to view your property simultaneously, creating a sense of urgency and competition among interested parties. 

Don’t forget to spread the work of your home sale throughout your social circle. 18% of home buyers first hear about a property through friends, relatives, or neighbors. The more people know about your house, the higher the chance that the right buyer finds out about it.

Being Unavailable for Showings

When scheduling showings, flexibility is important to attract potential buyers. Make your home available for showings at various times, including evenings and weekends. The more accessible your home is, the higher the chances of receiving offers. Consider using scheduling tools that allow potential buyers to book appointments easily.

When showing your home, consider allowing potential buyers to explore without your presence. Buyers often feel more comfortable viewing properties on their own terms without feeling rushed or watched. This approach allows them to discuss the property openly with their agents. Be prepared for last-minute showings as well. If you receive a request from an interested buyer's agent, try to accommodate it if possible.

Not Understanding Legal Requirements

The legal aspects of selling a home can be complex and confusing for home sellers. Missing one or more of the legal requirements could lead to complications later in the selling process. Familiarize yourself with the documents you need to provide when selling a home.

Research the mandatory disclosures in your area, such as lead paint or structural issues. Failing to disclose known problems can result in legal repercussions after the sale. Each state has specific laws regarding what must be disclosed so make sure you comply with these regulations. Remember to present the disclosure forms to potential buyers early on to avoid any issues.

Make sure to prepare any other legal documentation you need, such as the sales contract, deed, and title report, ahead of time. If you’re working with a real estate agent or an attorney, they can prepare these forms for you, making the transaction easier and smoother for you.

The image illustrates the consequences of skipping disclosures in a home sale. It includes three sections: failure to disclose lead paint, hiding structural problems, and missing forms, each explained with accompanying visuals and text.
The Consequences of Skipping Disclosures

Neglecting Buyer Prequalification

Accepting offers from unqualified buyers can waste time and lead to frustration during negotiations. Always verify mortgage preapproval letters before considering offers. This step ensures that potential buyers have the financial capability to purchase your home. A preapproval letter indicates that a lender has reviewed the buyer's financial situation and deemed them capable of securing financing up to a certain amount.

By focusing on prequalified buyers, you increase the likelihood of closing successfully and reduce the chances of dealing with financing-related issues later in the process. If you receive multiple offers, prioritize those with verified preapproval over those without it.

Pay attention to contingency clauses in offers as well. Some buyers may include contingencies that could delay or complicate the sale process, such as needing to sell their current home first. Be sure to evaluate these carefully when considering offers.

Emotional Involvement in Negotiations

Selling a home is often an emotional experience, but allowing feelings to interfere with negotiations can complicate the selling process. Sellers should strive to remain objective throughout the negotiation process. Overreacting to lowball offers or taking buyer feedback personally can hinder effective communication and lead to missed opportunities. Remember that negotiations are part of business; try not to take comments about your home’s value personally.

Establish clear boundaries regarding what terms are acceptable before entering negotiations. This allows you to remain focused on achieving those goals rather than getting sidetracked by emotions during discussions with potential buyers.

If you’re unsure about the effect your emotions would have on the selling process, consider working with an experienced real estate agent. An agent acts as an intermediary who can present counteroffers without personal bias affecting decisions.

Mismanaging the Closing Process

The closing process involves numerous details that require careful management. Failing to track each factor effectively can lead to delays or complications. It’s important to coordinate with inspectors, appraisers, and other professionals involved in the closing process. Forgetting deadlines for contingencies or failing to prepare necessary documents can jeopardize the sale. Create a checklist of tasks needed before the closing day so nothing falls through the cracks.

Be aware of closing costs and final expenses associated with selling your home. Closing costs typically include agent commissions, title insurance fees, transfer taxes, and other related expenses. Knowing these figures upfront allows you better financial planning throughout this phase.

Don’t overlook final walkthroughs either! Buyers usually conduct one last inspection shortly before closing; make sure everything remains in good condition post-inspection so they feel confident moving forward with their purchase decision without surprises at settlement time.

Bar chart titled Where Do Closing Costs Go? with categories: Agent commissions (largest in orange), Title insurance fees, Transfer taxes, Escrow fees, and Misc (all in blue). X-axis shows Percentage of Sale from 0 to 12%.
Where Do Closing Costs Go?

Conclusion

Selling a home requires careful planning and execution. To increase your chances of a successful sale, look out for the eight common mistakes we discussed in this article. Taking proactive steps to avoid these mistakes will maximize your financial return while keeping the selling experience smooth and free from complications.

If you’re finding it difficult to price your home accurately, handle legal documents, and market your property, you should give Propbox a try. Propbox is an AI-powered online platform for homeowners who are selling their homes without the help of a realtor. This tool can help you save money, sell efficiently, and maintain control over the whole process.

With Propbox, you can always be on top of the situation. Get information on the local housing market, set reminders for legal documents, and let Propbox do the marketing for you. You won’t need a real estate agent either, so you can maximize your home’s value by avoiding paying the commission fee.

linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram